Erin Hill
Gadsden County News Service
After months of debate over where to build a proposed Boys & Girls Club and community center, the Gadsden County Board of County Commissioners voted 4-1 on Oct. 20 to move forward with the Strong Road property if plans to purchase the New Life property do not work out.
Commissioner Brenda Holt made the motion, with Commissioner Alonzetta Simpkins seconding it. Chairman Eric Hinson cast the lone dissenting vote.
The decision followed another lengthy discussion about potential locations, the county’s negotiations with property owners and whether the project could move forward without jeopardizing state funding.
The New Life property remained the preferred option under the motion, while the county-owned Strong Road site would serve as an alternative.
The project has been under discussion for several years, with commissioners divided over which location would best serve the county’s children and provide the most practical use of available funding.
At the Oct. 6 meeting, commissioners considered moving forward with the Strong Road property but ultimately voted unanimously to table the decision until a special meeting could be held.
During the Oct. 20 meeting, Interim County Administrator Reginald James said the county had conducted due diligence on the New Life property.
Interim County Attorney Louis Baptiste confirmed the county had received an offer from New Life and that the offer was part of the public record.
The New Life Ministries property at 640 S. Shelfer St. was offered to the county for $2.5 million, according to information presented during the Oct. 20 meeting. The proposal involved approximately 7.32 acres and existing facilities.
The property had previously been offered to the county for $1.29 million in October 2023. According to county records, that proposal included the front five acres and all buildings, with the church retaining the remaining two acres. An appraisal completed in May 2023 placed the property’s value at approximately $850,000.
However, questions remained about the purchase, the condition of existing structures and the requirements attached to the project’s funding.
Baptiste explained that county officials had spoken with representatives of FloridaCommerce about the possibility of purchasing property containing an existing building. He said the language governing the grant and the project’s scope of work would have to be changed if the county pursued renovation rather than new construction.
Commissioner Ronterious Green questioned whether the county would still be required to construct a new building if it purchased property with an existing structure.
Green also expressed frustration with the amount of information commissioners had received before being asked to make a decision.
Commissioner Shawn Wood questioned whether the county could construct a facility on property it did not own. Other commissioners raised concerns about the financial and legal implications of the available options.
The discussion also brought renewed attention to the city of Quincy’s involvement in the project.
Quincy Mayor Robin Wood appeared before commissioners and said the city was interested in offering property near the Quincy Recreation Center. She explained that the city preferred to retain ownership of the property rather than give it away.
Wood also addressed concerns about communication between the city and county, saying she preferred a face-to-face meeting between the two commissions to discuss the project.
Green said he was encouraged by the possibility of cooperation between the two governments but acknowledged that previous efforts to arrange discussions had not been successful.
Baptiste said he had recommended a meeting between city and county leaders to discuss the details, but the proposal had been rejected by the city attorney.
Several residents and community representatives also weighed in on the project.
Antonio Jefferson, speaking on behalf of the Boys & Girls Club, said the Strong Road property was the organization’s preferred location. He also emphasized the importance of security in selecting a site.
Resident Ann Marie Chupa told commissioners the primary consideration should be the best interests of the children who would use the facility.
Commissioners also discussed money already spent on other proposed locations, including the Wards lot, and whether changes to the plans could affect the amount of space available for the facility.
The debate reflected continuing differences among commissioners over location, accessibility, existing infrastructure and the long-term needs of the community.
Although the board approved a path forward, the vote did not resolve every question surrounding the project. The county must still determine whether the New Life property can be acquired and whether the selected location meets applicable funding and construction requirements.
The Strong Road property will remain the alternative if the New Life purchase cannot be completed.
