Ask Judge Smith – Republic or Democracy?

Q. Judge Smith, I’m in middle school and want to be a lawyer when I grow up. Which do you think is better, a republic or a democracy? — Sue

A. Sue, you have the perfect name for a lawyer! All kidding aside, I’m delighted that you want to be one. Now, let’s discuss republics and democracies. The most noteworthy ancient republic was Rome before it became an empire. In fact, the word republic is derived from the Latin phrase res publica, which means “the laws.”

The Roman republic was governed by a senate, who established its laws. Roman senators were wealthy male aristocrats. They weren’t elected by the people. Both our federal and state governments are republics. When I became a lawyer, and later when I became a county judge, I swore an oath to support, protect, and defend the constitutions and governments of the United States and of the State of Florida.

I have always lived faithfully by those oaths. As a future lawyer, one day you’ll take a similar oath when you become a member of a state’s bar. In our Republic, the people don’t directly vote on every political issue. Instead, through the democratic process, we elect senators and representatives who decide political issues and establish public policy on our behalf.

While the majority tends to get its way, “the laws” protect us from the “tyranny of the mob” that might otherwise follow.

Both the constitution and our courts’ faithful application of the rule of law prevent the majority from running roughshod over minorities and people with unpopular views.

The most noteworthy ancient democracies were the Greek city-states.

The word democracy is derived from the Greek words demos and kratein, which means “the people to rule.”

In a democracy, political issues are decided by a majority vote of the people. Democracies don’t protect minorities and people with unpopular views. Also, while democracies might be practical in small city-states, democracies are too unwieldy to function in large nations. Imagine how impractical and expensive it would be to hold national elections on every political issue that confronts us, much less the potential for recounts!

In 1787, the Constitutional Convention met in private. When it adjourned, the public did not know which form of government the delegates were recommending. When asked by a curious Philadelphian if it was to be a republic or a monarchy, Benjamin Franklin responded, “A republic, if you can keep it.” Two centuries later, President Reagan rightly described the American people and our government as “the last best hope of man on earth.”

My direct answer to your question is less important than what you think.

Given my explanation of the two, which form of government do you think is best?

Sue, behave, study hard, and respect your elders. I invite you to schedule a day during your summer vacation to visit the courthouse and shadow a judge. Stay curious and think for yourself!

The Honorable J. Layne Smith is a Circuit Judge, bestselling author, and public speaker. - Send questions to askjudgesmith@gmail.com

Ask Judge Smith – Republic or Democracy?

CAT TALES – Wynken and Blynken

Havana museum to spotlight the contributions of women in the military

Havana museum to spotlight the contributions of women in the military

Recommended

Tallahassee Community College adds three bachelor’s degree programs – The community collage’s officials anticipates education programs will fill in the gap of critical teacher shortage areas

Chattahoochee celebrates freedom and unity on July 4

Popular News

Quincy commissioners address social media photo, investigation into utility department deposits

County commissioners approve property tax increase, despite pushback

PumpkinFest brings fall fun to Downtown Havana this weekend

Farm Credit of Northwest Florida announces the 2026 AgVocator Scholarship Program

Court curbs searches based on pot smell

Newsletter

Category

Site Links

About Us

Welcome Back!

Create New Account!

Retrieve your password

Are you sure want to unlock this post?

Are you sure want to cancel subscription?

Ask Judge Smith – Republic or Democracy?

Support local journalism. Subscribe to The Gadsden County Times.

Subscribe

CAT TALES – Wynken and Blynken

Havana museum to spotlight the contributions of women in the military

Recommended

Popular News

Newsletter

Category

Site Links

About Us

Welcome Back!

Create New Account!

Retrieve your password

Are you sure want to unlock this post?

Are you sure want to cancel subscription?